1912: MCAU
1918: MCAU
1925: MCAU
1926: MCAU
1927: MCAU
1928: MCAU
1960: MCAU
1961: MCAU
1994: SLIAC Tournament
1995: SLIAC Tournament
1999: SLIAC Tournament
2000: * SLIAC
2001: * SLIAC

MCAU-Missouri College Athletic Union
SLIAC-St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference
* NCAA Division III National Tournament Qualifier