All-Tournament Team (SLIAC)
2005: Matt Cook, Sr., 1B
Billy Palmer, Jr., OF
2006: Ryan Dailey, Sr., DH/P
Joe Leake, Fr., SS
All-Conference (SLIAC)
1993: Jay Custard, IF, First Team
Jon Robertson, C, First Team
Ehren Earleywine, IF, Second Team
Rich Sturm, OF, Second Team
Wes Higgins, IF, Honorable Mention
1994: Jay Custard, IF, First Team
Jon Robertson, C, First Team
Sean Rogan, P, First Team
Rich Sturm, OF, First Team
Jamie Tennyson, P, Second Team
Eli Bridge, P, Honorable Mention
Michael Garrett, OF, Honorable Mention
Sam Harper, IF, Honorable Mention
1995: Mike Howell, 2B, First Team
Sean Rogan, OF/P First Team
1996: Brandon Beissenherz, OF, First Team
Pat Berry, C, First Team
Jay Custard, 3B, First Team
Gary Andrews, OF, Second Team
Brandon Eckardt, DH, Second Team
Trey Herweck, 1B, Second Team
Chris Kipper, OF, Honorable Mention
Austin Power, P, Honorable Mention
Bryan Reed, SS, Honorable Mention
Steve Shirley, UT, Honorable Mention
Dwight Ternes, 2B, Honorable Mention
1997: Gary Andrews, OF, First Team
Pat Berry, C, Second Team
Spencer Bartlett, DH, Second Team
Austin Power, P, Honorable Mention
Steve Shirley, OF, Honorable Mention
1998: Dan Bean, OF/P, First Team
Brandon Beissenherz, OF, Second Team
Mark Gifford, 3B, Second Team
Chris Pemberton, P, Second Team
Jeff Stubbs, P, Second Team
Tyler Schaper, OF, Honorable Mention
1999: Dan Bean, UT, First Team
Brandon Beissenherz, OF, First Team
Chris Pemberton, P, First Team
Tommy Tarpley, 1B, First Team
Pat Kipper, SS, Second Team
Dan Bean, OF, Honorable Mention
2000: Paul Moyer, P, First Team
Tim Ode, P, First Team
Cory Roper, OF, First Team
Mark Gifford, 3B, Second Team
Pat Kipper, SS, Second Team
Jeff Cleve, P, Honorable Mention
Tom McConnell, 2B, Honorable Mention
Cory Metz, C, Honorable Mention
2001: Justin Freesmeier, SS, First Team
Mark Gifford, 3B, First Team
Paul Moyer, P, First Team
Pat Ricke, DH, First Team
Cory Roper, OF, First Team
Nick Aboussie, OF, Second Team
Cory Metz, C, Second Team
Mike Rosch, 1B, Second Team
Nick Cacciabando, P, Honorable Mention
Tom McConnell, 2B, Honorable Mention
2002: Nick Cacciabando, P, Second Team
Justin Freesmeier, 2B, Second Team
Ryan Brodecker, P, Honorable Mention
Joel Heuring, OF, Honorable Mention
Pat Ricke, OF, Honorable Mention
Mike Rosch, 1B, Honorable Mention
2003: Ryan Dailey, P, First Team
John Miller, 2B, First Team
Pat Ricke, OF, First Team
Nick Cacciabando, P, Second Team
Shaun Duvall, DH, Second Team
Joel Heuring, OF, Second Team
Troy Walker, 1B, Second Team
Ryan Brodecker, P, Honorable Mention
Evan Prout, 3B, Honorable Mention
2004: Nate Summers, P, Second Team
Alex Shelton, 2B, Honorable Mention
Troy Walker, 1B, Honorable Mention
2005: Chris Collins, C, First Team
Billy Palmer, OF, First Team
Alex Shelton, 2B, First Team
Troy Walker, DH, First Team
Brian Donaldson, P, Second Team
Nate Summers, P, Second Team
Matt Cook, 1B, Honorable Mention
2006: Chris Collins, C, First Team
Joe Leake, 3B, First Team
Billy Palmer, OF, First Team
Ryan Dailey, DH, Second Team
James Manning, 1B, Second Team
Kevin Pearre, P, Second Team
Alex Shelton, 2B, Honorable Mention
2007: Aaron Miller, C, Second Team
Joe Leake, SS, Second Team
Phil Walter, DH, Second Team
2008: Joe Leake, SS, First Team
Mike Silver, DH, First Team
Jesse Jett, 3B, Second Team
Mike Oliveri, P, Honorable Mention
VJ Reynolds, OF, Honorable Mention
Grant Shell, 1B, Honorable Mention
SLIAC Tournament MVP
1994: Rich Sturm, Sr., OF
1995: Sean Rogan, Sr., P
1999: Dan Bean, Sr., P/UT
SLIAC Player of the Year
2000: Paul Moyer, Jr., P/1B
2001: Paul Moyer, Sr., P/1B
SLIAC Coach of the Year
2000: Scott Pritchard
2001: Scott Pritchard
ABCA Division III All-Central Region
2000: Paul Moyer, Jr., P, Second Team
Cory Roper, Jr., OF, Second Team
Tim Ode, Jr., P, Honorable Mention
2001: Paul Moyer, Sr., P, First Team
Cory Roper, Sr., OF, First Team
Nick Aboussie, Sr., OF, Honorable Mention
Cory Metz, Jr., C, Honorable Mention
Pat Ricke, So., DH, Honorable Mention
NCAA Central Regional All-Tournament Team
2001: Tom McConnell, Sr., 2B
Tim Ode, Sr., P
Academic All-Conference (SLIAC)
1991: John Fieberg
1992: Chris Kiefer
Jamie Tennyson
1993: Jamie Tennyson
1994: Eli Bridge
1996: Eli Bridge
1997: Spencer Bartlett
Eli Bridge
1998: Mark Gifford
Chris Pemberton
1999: Mark Gifford
Ty Hawkins
Chris Pemberton
2000: Chad Ezell
Mark Gifford
Jason Overbey
2001: Mark Gifford
2003: Alex Shelton
2004: James Manning
Jon Miesner
Alex Shelton
2005: Brendon Magruder
Billy Palmer
Alex Shelton
Phillip Stoll
2006: Eric Brueckner
Billy Palmer
Alex Shelton
Phillip Stoll
Ben Toben
2007: Jimmy Gesling
Dale Schenewerk
Phillip Stoll
2008: Jimmy Gesling
Dale Schenewerk
Mike Silver
Phillip Stoll
CoSida Academic All-District VII
1999: Chris Pemberton, Sr., First Team
Tommy Tarpley, Jr., Second Team
2001: Mark Gifford, Sr., First Team
2005: Alex Shelton, Jr., First Team
2006: Alex Shelton, Sr., First Team
CoSida Academic All-America
2001: Mark Gifford, Sr., Second Team
2005: Alex Shelton, Jr., Second Team
2006: Alex Shelton, Sr., Third Team
NAIA All-District 16
1986: Ken Theroff, First team
Craig McIntosh, Second Team
1987: David Reinkemeyer, Second Team
Rusty Byrne, Honorable Mention
Mike Horstman, Honorable Mention
Mike Kim, Honorable Mention
Mike Knight, Honorable Mention
Scott Nilsen, Honorable Mention
Ken Theroff, Honorable Mention
1988: Paul Azar, Honorable Mention
Greg Ramsbottom, Honorable Mention
Craig McIntosh, Honorable Mention
1989: Mike Antonacci, First Team
Brad Marcks, First Team
Kirk Mendenhall, First Team
Pat Lane, Honorable Mention
Daren Masek, Honorable Mention
1990: Mike Antonacci, First Team
Kerry Lasater, First Team
Kirk Mendenhall, First Team
Brad Marcks, Second Team
Jeff Ramsey, Second Team
John Lynn, Honorable Mention
Sean Newton, Honorable Mention
John Wilson, Honorable Mention
1991: Chris Bax, First Team
1992: Ehren Earleywine, First Team
Brian Marsaglia, First Team
Wes Higgins, Honorable Mention
Sean Rogan, Honorable Mention
Rich Sturm, Honorable Mention
NAIA All-Area 4
1990: Kirk Mendenhall, First Team
NAIA All-American
1990: Kirk Mendenhall, Second Team
NAIA All-America Scholar-Athlete
1989: Brad Marcks, Jr.